Tuesday, August 16, 2016

The All Souls Trilogy, Deborah Harkness

I've been accused -- probably justifiably -- of being a snob. I've been known to be dismissive of genre fiction. I've tried to be better and less judgmental. The All Souls trilogy was a total departure from my normal reading material -- one that made me a bit uncomfortable. Their genre could be described as historical fantasy with a healthy dose of romance. The central characters are a witch and a vampire. Aside from Roald Dahl's The Witches, I don't think I'd ever read a witch book, and I'd definitely never read a vampire book before.

While I'm not the kind of person who ostentatiously reads ~literature~ on the subway (I mean, I do read literature on the subway, but not for the attention it gets me, if you see what I'm saying), I was self-conscious reading these books on the subway. I knew it was dumb to care, but when I read standing over people, I wondered what they thought of the back-cover blurbs about vampires and witches. When I read sitting next to people, I held the book close. God forbid someone should read one of the vampire-witch sex scenes over my shoulder.

But, um, let's see... I enjoyed these books. I devoured these books. I couldn't put them down. I think I liked the first book, A Discovery of Witches, the least. Of all of them, it was the most formulaic and romance-ish (but without the payoff, wtf?!). The second book, Shadow of Night, nearly all of which takes place in the 16th century (and in which the protagonists finally consummate their relationship), was fun! The final book in the trilogy, The Book of Life, was my favorite, and I read it over a period of less than 36 hours. I was so sad when I finished it. Plus the books were smart. Not, like, overly so, but smart enough. I could read more books like this. What are they?